all purpose flour allspice apple cider vinegar baking powder baking soda bay leaf beef broth beef stock bell pepper black pepper brown sugar butter cayenne pepper chili powder clove cornstarch cumin dried thyme leaf egg flour fresh ground black pepper fresh thyme garlic garlic clove garlic powder ginger granny smith apple granulated sugar ground cinnamon ground cumin ground pork kosher salt light brown sugar lime juice milk nutmeg oil olive oil onion paprika salt sugar unsalted butter vanilla extract vegetable oil water worcestershire sauce